A search for the needle in the dog

A search for the needle in the dog

We are searching data for your request:

Forums and discussions:
Manuals and reference books:
Data from registers:
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.

District court Mülheim / Ruhr complains of documentation errors by the veterinarian
Mülheim / Ruhr (jur). If a veterinarian has not documented an unsuccessful dog operation and then also slows down the x-rays, he cannot claim a fee. This was decided by the Mülheim an der Ruhr district court in a recently published judgment of July 21, 2016 (file number: 23 C 489/15).

Specifically, it was about the mixed breed bitch “Sally”, who was brought to a veterinary practice by her owner in July 2014 because of seizures all over her body. After taking x-rays, the vets discovered that the dog had swallowed a sewing needle that was located between the esophagus and the stomach.

The veterinarians agreed with the dog owner that they wanted to remove the needle by palpation. But during the operation the needle was not found in the dog, so that Sally's stomach and belly were closed again.

The doctors of the veterinary practice issued the dog owner several invoices totaling 1,218 euros for the unsuccessful operation. However, the dog owner did not pay.

The district court decided not to. Because the veterinarians had insufficiently documented the intervention. There is no detailed operation report showing from which side Sally's stomach was opened. In particular, the x-rays taken are no longer available. So it can no longer be determined whether the dog was X-rayed and operated incorrectly.

"A surgeon is not allowed to work like this during his successful operations, least of all with his failed ones", the district court ruled on the lack of documentation. The veterinarians could therefore not prove that they worked according to the rules of veterinary art. They are therefore not entitled to any remuneration.

The dog is well again. In a veterinary clinic, the needle that has now moved into the lungs was removed. fle

Author and source information

Video: PUPPY gets a NEEDLE! FIRST CHECK-UP at the VET (July 2022).


  1. Manly

    mmm Right.

  2. Duk

    What words... super, excellent idea

  3. Emmanuele

    Completely I share your opinion. In it something is also to me your idea is pleasant. I suggest to take out for the general discussion.

  4. Stanwik

    the phrase Incomparable, pleases me very much :)

  5. Quirin

    You are not right. Let's discuss this. Email me at PM.

  6. Anwar

    It was specially registered at a forum to tell to you thanks for council. How I can thank you?

  7. Dubei

    I congratulate this remarkable idea just about

Write a message